Cold calling works better for people who answer their own phones and make decisions on the spot: owners of small shops, trades and restaurants. Cold email works better for people who sit at a desk, have a gatekeeper, and read their inbox in batches. You can use both, each for the buyers it suits.
I won't give you a success rate for either, because the figures floating around come from very different industries and can't be trusted for yours. Instead, here's how to choose by buyer, how to split a list between the two, and a one-week test that gives you your own numbers.
What each channel is good at
A phone call is fast and personal. In two minutes you can find out whether there's a need, hear the tone of the answer, and book a time. It's also interruptive: you're asking someone to stop what they're doing, which is why most calls to strangers end quickly.
An email is easy to ignore and easy to answer. The reader can respond at 9pm, forward it to a colleague, or look you up first. You can say something specific and give them time to consider it. It scales better, since one email can go to a long list, but a reply isn't guaranteed to come.
Who answers the phone
People whose phone number is on a sign, a truck or a Google listing answer calls for a living: the owner of a bakery, the manager of a small clinic, a lawn-care owner. They expect calls from strangers because customers call them. The best times are usually before the lunch rush or mid-afternoon, not during service.
People further up an organization usually don't. A facilities director at a hospital, a procurement manager at a school district or a finance lead at a mid-size company has a direct line behind a front desk or a screening assistant. Cold calls get screened out. If the front desk is your obstacle, how to get past the gatekeeper when cold calling gives you the exact words, and a sales call script for a local business owner covers the call itself.
Who answers email
Office-based buyers read email all day. A property manager, an HR director or an IT lead will skim a short, specific note between meetings and reply if it matches something on their plate. They often prefer it, since they can answer when they're ready and forward it to whoever owns the decision.
Email also reaches people who are hard to phone, like those who travel, work remotely, or sit in meetings. But their inboxes are crowded, so a vague message disappears. Short, specific and relevant is what gets a reply. For writing email that doesn't read as spam, cold email that is not spam has examples, and LinkedIn outreach versus email covers the third channel.
Splitting a list between the two
The simplest way to use both is to let the buyer decide. Sort your list by who the person is. Owners of shops, trades and restaurants, whose number is public and who answer it, go on the call list. Office managers, directors and anyone behind a front desk go on the email list. Someone who answers you on one channel stays on that channel, and a good question to ask in any conversation is how they would rather be reached.
Calling a short list is quick, and email scales to a long one. A person who has told you "email me" belongs on the email list, and one who says "call me" should get a call. The log in the last section is where you keep that preference.
Mind the rules for each. In the US, commercial email needs an accurate sender line, a postal address and a working opt-out (CAN-SPAM). Calls to numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry are restricted for consumer sales, and rules differ for business-to-business calls and by state; check yours. Texting needs prior consent (TCPA). Keep email volume modest, around 20 to 50 a day per inbox at first.
A one-week test
Let's say you sell commercial window cleaning, and your list is 40 people: 20 shop and restaurant owners, 20 office managers. Here's a fair test. Within each group, give half the people the call and half the email, so each person gets one channel and the same offer.
- Shop and restaurant owners: call 10, email the other 10.
- Office managers: call 10, email the other 10.
- Use the same offer and the same first sentence in both channels.
- Log every attempt the day it happens.
- At the end of the week, count.
For each group and each channel, count replies and conversations. You may find shop owners say yes on the phone and ignore email, while office managers reply by email and screen calls. Or the opposite. The point is to see which works for your buyer, not for buyers in general. With 10 people in each cell, the sample is small, so repeat with another 40 before trusting the result.
Here is how a result might read, with invented numbers. Of the 10 shop owners called, 6 were reached, 3 had a real conversation and 2 asked for a quote; of the 10 emailed, 1 replied and none asked for a quote. Of the 10 office managers called, 1 was reached and none talked; of the 10 emailed, 3 replied and 2 asked for a quote. On those numbers the shop owners are a phone group and the office managers an email group, and you would write your next 40 accordingly. If both groups behaved the same, pick the cheaper channel in minutes and move on.
Time cost of each
Calls cost more minutes per contact. Ten calls, including the ones that go to voicemail, take 30 to 45 minutes. Ten emails written with a specific first line take about the same. The difference is in the follow-up: a follow-up email takes a minute; another call attempt takes five.
That's the main reason people drop calling: nobody finds the time to keep dialing. For the question of who should be doing it, should founders do their own cold outreach.
What to log
One row per person. Columns: name, business, channel tried, date, outcome (no answer, voicemail, talked, replied), next step and date, and how they said they prefer to be reached. At the end of the week add up outcomes by channel and buyer type. Without the log you'll remember the one good call and forget the nine silent ones.
Rocketship handles the email half on its own and the calling half in part. Its AI salesperson finds buyers by name, emails them from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting, and Launch can make AI phone calls (calls use 8 credits a minute; a dedicated line is $5 a month). That leaves the calls where your voice matters for you. The guide to AI cold calling explains what the AI calls should and shouldn't be used for, and the AI salesperson page lists what it covers.
Pick the channel your buyer uses. Rather than dial the whole list yourself, let Rocketship's AI salesperson email and call it for you, follow up, and put the meetings that come out of it on your calendar. For a look at how it behaves on your own buyers, take the free trial of 7 days; a card is required.