For a first cold email from your own Gmail, send it plain: a few short paragraphs of text, a signature of three or four lines, no images, no banner, no buttons. A plain email looks like what a person writes, there is less in it for a filter to react to, and the reader sees one thing to answer. HTML earns its place in newsletters and announcements, not in a note to a stranger who has never heard of you. I know of no published study that settles this for cold email, so the last section gives you a 50-person test that settles it for your own list.
The one source I lean on is Google's own Email sender guidelines for Gmail, read on 2026-11-20. It says to format HTML messages according to HTML standards and not to use HTML and CSS to hide content, and it says links in the message body should be visible and easy to understand. None of that forbids HTML. It sets the floor: whatever you send has to be clean.
What changes between the two
| Element | Plain text | HTML |
|---|---|---|
| Look | One font, no colors | Fonts, colors, layout, buttons |
| Images | None | Logos, banners, headshots |
| Links | The address written out | Words that hide the address, tracked redirects |
| What it signals | A person wrote this | A company sent this |
| Where it fits | A first note to one person | A newsletter, a launch, a receipt |
The last two rows are the real argument. A cold email works when the reader believes you chose them, and the look of the message is the first evidence. A designed message with a logo and a button reads as a mass mailing, even if you wrote every word for that one person.
What "plain" means in Gmail
Gmail's compose window has a plain text mode in its more-options menu, which strips formatting from what you write. You do not have to use it to send a plain email. Typing in the normal compose box with no bold, no colors, no inserted images and no pasted formatting gives you a message that looks plain. Two traps are worth knowing. Pasting from a web page or a document brings its fonts and colors along. And a signature copied from a corporate template can carry a logo and a legal block that turns a three-line note into a banner. Paste into the box with "paste as plain text" (Ctrl+Shift+V on Windows, Command+Shift+V on a Mac) and write a short signature by hand.
The signature, in four lines
A plain signature carries your name, what you do in a few words, the business and a postal address. A US sender needs the address anyway, and the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says it must be a valid one, covered in what CAN-SPAM accepts as an address. The longer treatment is in how to write a cold email signature.
Dana Okafor
Okafor Bookkeeping, monthly books for dental practices
[PO box or street address, city, state, ZIP]
Links and images
Google's guidance asks for links that are visible and easy to understand. In a plain email that is easy: write the address as text, or leave the link out of the first message altogether. Links are a topic of their own, covered in whether to put links in a cold email. As for images, the first email does not need one. A tracking pixel is an image, too, a one-pixel one, and what it tells you is unreliable, which is why stop measuring opens argues against building decisions on it.
Attachments and phones
Leave attachments out of the first email. A file from a stranger is the thing most people have been taught not to open, and it adds weight and a reason for a filter to look closer. If a document is the point, say what it is and offer to send it, the way the links page suggests for a link.
Read your email on a phone before you send it. Most business email is opened on one at some point, and a plain message handles a narrow screen better than a designed one. Short paragraphs, one idea each, no table. If you have to scroll to find the question, the email is too long. How long is covered in how long should a cold email be.
The 50-person test
Take 100 people from one list, similar in role and size. Split them into two groups of 50 at random. Send group one a plain version and group two an HTML version with the same words, subject and sender. Count replies after a week. With groups this small, a gap of two or three replies is noise. Only a big gap tells you something, and the number that matters is replies, not opens. If both versions get similar replies, stay plain: it costs less and fails less. If HTML wins by a lot with your audience, you have a fact about your list that no article could give you.
When HTML is fine
- A message to people who already know you: customers, newsletter subscribers, event attendees.
- A product announcement to an existing list.
- A message where a table or a price list is the content.
Even then, keep it clean by Google's standard: valid HTML, nothing hidden, links that say where they go.
Whichever format you choose, the work that decides the reply is the list and the first line. Rocketship finds the right people by job title, industry and place, writes and sends from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting. You can see the plans, from $12 a month, on the pricing page. Every monthly plan starts with a 7-day free trial, card required, and you can cancel any time before day 8.