Price a project when the work has a defined deliverable and an end date, and price a retainer when the work is ongoing, the scope shifts month to month, or the client needs you available. The difference is who carries the risk. A project fee puts the risk of running over on you and rewards you for finishing early. A retainer puts a ceiling on your time, gives you steady income and gives the client first call on you. Below is one engagement priced three ways, so you can see where each model pays and where it hurts.
This is for consultants and agencies that sell time and expertise: strategy, marketing, operations, design, development. If you are still deciding between charging by the hour and by the job, read hourly rate versus flat fee first, then come back.
One engagement, three prices
Suppose Tomas, an operations consultant, is asked to improve a client's order-handling process over six months. His honest estimate is 120 hours of work, and his rate is $150 an hour. He can quote it three ways.
- Project: $18,000 fixed, for a defined set of deliverables (the process map, the new workflow, training, a 30-day check). That is 120 x $150 = $18,000.
- Retainer: $3,000 a month for six months, covering up to 20 hours a month. That is 6 x $3,000 = $18,000, and 6 x 20 = 120 hours. Hours past 20 in a month bill at $150.
- Hourly: $150 for each hour worked, reported monthly.
Now watch what each model does when the real work is different from the estimate.
| Model | If the work takes 90 hours | 120 hours | 160 hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Project, $18,000 | $18,000 ($200 an hour) | $18,000 ($150) | $18,000 ($112.50) |
| Retainer, 20 hours a month | $18,000 ($200) | $18,000 ($150) | $24,000 ($150) |
| Hourly, $150 | $13,500 ($150) | $18,000 ($150) | $24,000 ($150) |
The arithmetic: 18,000 divided by 90 is $200, and 18,000 divided by 160 is $112.50. For the retainer at 160 hours, the first 120 are covered by $18,000 and the extra 40 bill at $150, which is $6,000, for $24,000 in all. Hourly at 90 hours is 90 x $150 = $13,500, and at 160 hours is 160 x $150 = $24,000.
Read the first column and the last. A project fee pays you more when you finish quickly and less when the client keeps adding work. Hourly pays the same whatever happens, which makes it safe for you and unpredictable for the client. The retainer sits between them: it protects your income when the work is light, and it stops you giving away hours when it is heavy, because the extra ones are billed.
When the project fee is the right call
- The deliverable can be written in one paragraph and the client can tell when it is done.
- You have done similar work before and your estimate is reliable.
- The client wants a firm total before they will sign.
- You expect to finish faster than the market assumes.
The danger is scope creep. Write down what is in, what is out and what a change costs, and hold to it. A project fee with a loose scope is an hourly job that pays you less.
When a retainer is the right call
- The work is ongoing: content, advertising management, reporting, advice, system care.
- The client wants access to you more than a finished product.
- You are tired of selling a new job every month and want income you can plan.
- The scope changes as results come in, so a fixed deliverable would be fiction.
The danger is a vague retainer. Define what the monthly block covers, how fast you respond, what happens to unused hours, and how the client cancels. The proposal side is covered in how to ask a client for a retainer.
What each model does to your capacity
Take a consultant with 80 billable hours a month. Three retainers at 20 hours each commit 60 hours, which is 75 percent of capacity (60 divided by 80), and leave 20 hours for projects and sales. If the same consultant sells only projects, income swings with each sale. A month with no signed project is a month with no revenue, and a month with two overlapping projects is a month of overtime. That swing is the reason to run a base of retainers and add projects on top.
The hybrid: a project, then a retainer
One pairing that uses both is a project fee for the build or the first phase, followed by a smaller retainer to keep it running. Natalia, who runs a design studio, quotes a $12,000 website and an $810 monthly care plan, and presents both on one page so the client sees the whole cost of ownership. The method for doing that is in how much to charge for consulting, which starts from the income you need and works back to a rate.
Five checks to decide
- The end. A deliverable and a date point to a project. No end points to a retainer.
- Your estimate. If it is a guess, use a retainer or hourly, or add a buffer to the project.
- The client's need. A repeating need favours a retainer.
- The client's finance team. Some budget by project, some by month, so ask.
- Your own month. If cash arrives unevenly, add retainers.
Whichever you choose, review it after the first three jobs. Compare the hours you spent with the fee, and move the price, not your standards, when the numbers disagree.
A consultant or agency still has to find the next client. Rocketship's AI salesperson finds the businesses you describe, emails them from your own Gmail, answers replies and books the meeting, from $12 a month; see the plans. Every plan has a 7-day trial, card required. It will not price your engagement for you.