For roofers, the alternative to Thumbtack leads is commercial work that you go and find: flat roof repairs and re-roofs on warehouses, retail centers and apartment buildings, and yearly maintenance programs for the property managers who own those roofs. The buyer is a person with a list of buildings and a budget line for roofs. Below is what each job type is worth, how to offer a roof inspection that gets a reply, and the arithmetic against paying per lead.
Dale Okonkwo owns a roofing company in Omaha with two crews. Most of his work is single-family re-roofs, and he pays for leads on a marketplace. He wants to know what a property manager with 12 buildings is worth. The numbers are assumptions chosen to show the method.
Three kinds of roofing work, three kinds of buyer
| Work | Buyer | Job size (assumed) | Comes back? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family re-roof | A homeowner, so not what this page is about | $12,000 | Rarely |
| Commercial repair or recoat | Property manager, building owner | $4,000 to $25,000 | Yes, across buildings |
| Maintenance program | Property manager with 5 or more roofs | $300 a roof, twice a year | Yearly |
A maintenance program is the quiet one. Twelve roofs inspected and cleared twice a year at $300 each is 12 times $300 times 2, or $7,200 a year, and the program is how you hear about a failing roof before the manager calls someone else. That is a second reason to build it: the roofer who walks the roofs twice a year is the first to see the repairs they need.
Why paying per residential lead fits this poorly
Thumbtack's homepage, read November 15, 2026, says "millions of customers like you rely on Thumbtack to care for their homes." Its pro page says you "control your pricing and budget for leads" and lists no lead prices, and the help pages that explain lead pricing did not load that day, so no price is quoted here. Look up your own rate in your account.
Take Dale's assumed numbers. A lead costs $60 and half are answered. One in six of the answered ones becomes a re-roof. That is $60 divided by 0.5 divided by 0.1667, about $720 per booked job. On a $12,000 job at a 25 percent margin, that is $3,000 of gross profit and the lead cost is 24 percent of it. It can still pay, and the cost comes back every time you need a new job. A commercial manager who signs a $7,200 program, then sends you the repairs the inspections find, repays the cost of finding them many times.
The offer that gets a reply: a roof condition report
A property manager is unlikely to want a sales visit, and does need to know which roofs will fail first in order to budget. Offer a written condition report on one building or on every roof in the portfolio: photos, moisture or ponding notes, estimated remaining life and the repairs to do now versus later. Price it low or credit it against the first repair. Dale's offer is a report on the manager's oldest building, with a repair estimate he emails the same week.
This pairs with the roofing sites in how to get commercial roofing clients, and the phone version is in the roofing cold call script. Before you dial, read the FTC's guide to the Telemarketing Sales Rule (16 CFR Part 310), read November 15, 2026. It says "Most phone calls between a telemarketer and a business are exempt from the TSR," and it lists exceptions, including calls to induce the retail sale of nondurable office or cleaning supplies and calls that solicit individual employees to buy for their own use. The rule itself, 16 CFR 310.6(b)(7) on eCFR, read the same day, also keeps the bans on misrepresentation in 310.3(a)(2) and (4) for business calls, so what you say about price and the work must be true. State law is separate. Nebraska, where Dale works, has a Telemarketing and Prize Promotions Act written for "consumer telephone calls" (Neb. Rev. Stat. 86-216), and 86-215 defines consumer goods or services as those used for "personal, family, or household purposes and not for resale or for use or consumption in trade or business," so a call about a commercial building's roof reads as outside it (nebraskalegislature.gov, read November 15, 2026). Other states write their laws differently, so read your own state's statute before you dial.
One first message
Subject options: "Roof condition report for your oldest building" or "Question about your roof budget."
Hi {{first_name}},
I own a roofing company in Omaha that repairs and re-roofs commercial buildings: flat roofs, TPO, modified bitumen and metal. I would like to walk your oldest building and send you a written condition report with photos and an estimate of remaining life. If a repair turns out to be needed, the report fee is credited against it.
Who in your office decides which roofs get budget this year?
Dale Okonkwo
[Your company name, street address, city, state, ZIP]
Reply "no" and I will not write again.
Those two bottom lines are the CAN-SPAM requirements, and they apply to B2B. The FTC's CAN-SPAM guide, read November 15, 2026, says "The law makes no exception for business-to-business email" and lists a valid physical postal address and an easy way to opt out as requirements, with up to $53,088 in penalties for each separate email in violation.
Who to list
Start with property management companies that manage industrial, retail or multifamily buildings, then add owners of warehouses and apartment complexes that show a single owner name on county records. Add facilities managers at school districts and hospitals, who run large portfolios. Twenty-five managers with five or more roofs each is a first list worth testing, because each one is a portfolio, not a single building. If 3 reply and 2 allow a roof walk, you have a pilot. If none do, the report offer is the first thing to rewrite.
The general guide to marketplace costs, with the cost per booked job for a lead-based channel, is in Thumbtack alternatives for service businesses.
What Rocketship does here
Rocketship finds the property and facilities managers by title, industry, size and place, emails them from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the roof walk. It finds business buyers only and does not supply homeowner leads. Plans start at $12 a month, with a 7-day trial and a card required; see pricing. It will not inspect the roof or write the report.