Tools compared

Cold email tools for insurance agents

What is the best cold email software for insurance agents?

Mailshake lists email sequences, A/B testing and AI email writing and has no free trial, Instantly lists cold email with unlimited email accounts and sells its lead credits as separate plans, lemlist lists a lead database with LinkedIn automation on its Multichannel plan, and Mailmeteor does mail merge from Gmail, Google Sheets or Excel. Rocketship finds the buyers, sends from your own Gmail, follows up and books the meeting.

Our pick: Rocketship

Rocketship is the one we'd pick if you want the businesses found, emailed and booked in one account.

  • The table shows Mailshake has no free trial and Instantly sells lead credits as separate plans. Rocketship finds the people from the credits each plan includes.
  • It finds buyers by job title, industry and place, with work emails, and emails them from your own Gmail.
  • It follows up, answers replies and books the meeting on your calendar, in the same account.
  • Every plan has a price on its pricing page, and every monthly plan starts with a 7-day free trial (card required).

Founders, startups and teams looking to grow that want customers found and contacted from one account.

Try it on your own buyers

By the Rocketship team. Prices checked on each tool's own pricing page.

Five cold email tools, side by side

Cold email tools for insurance agents
ToolPrice as publishedWhat's includedSetupLimitsSource
RocketshipOur pick
  • Starter: $12/mo
  • Launch: $24.99/mo
  • Frontier: $79/mo
  • Mission Control: $1,499/mo

Monthly prices. 7-day free trial on every monthly plan.

Finds buyers by job title, industry and place, with work emails. Reads each company's website before the first email, sends from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting on your calendar. Launch and up also finds people on Reddit, Quora and LinkedIn asking for what you sell.Sign up, connect your Gmail and say who you want in plain words. 7-day free trial on every monthly plan. Card required, cancel any time.Credits a month: Starter 250, Launch 500, Frontier 1,500, Mission Control 30,000. A person found with a work email is 4 credits. Emails a day: Starter 20, Launch 70, Frontier 210, Mission Control 3,500.Our pricing pageChecked
Mailshake
  • Starter: $29/mo, or $25/mo on the yearly toggle
  • Email Outreach: $49/mo, or $45/mo on the yearly toggle
  • Sales Engagement: $99/mo, or $85/mo on the yearly toggle
  • Agency: talk to sales
  • Data Finder add-on: $19/mo, or $17/mo on the yearly toggle
  • Ready to Use Mailboxes add-on: $12/mo, or $11/mo on the yearly toggle

The page shows two figures per plan beside a Monthly and Yearly toggle without labeling them. The FAQ says billing is based on how many users you buy.

Starter: mail accounts from any provider, email sequences, A/B testing, AI email writing (SHAKESpeare), unlimited email warmup and verification. Email Outreach adds email rotation, a unified inbox, Salesforce, Pipedrive and HubSpot. Sales Engagement adds a power dialer with 5 phone numbers. Data Finder credits are included and sold as an add-on.No free trial. The FAQ says "we collect payment up front."Email addresses per account: Starter 1, Email Outreach 2, Sales Engagement 10. Sends a month: Starter 1,500, then unlimited. Data Finder credits: 50, 50 and 2,500. The page does not mention LinkedIn.Pricing pageChecked
Instantly
  • Growth: $47/mo, or $37.60/mo billed yearly
  • Hypergrowth: $358/mo on its bundle card and $107/mo in its outreach plans ($85.58/mo billed yearly)
  • Light Speed: $358/mo, or $286.30/mo billed yearly
  • Bundles: Starter $94/mo, Scale $194/mo, Agency $555/mo
  • Enterprise: no price on the page
  • Lead credits, sold as separate plans: from $47/mo

The page shows Hypergrowth at $358/mo on its bundle card and $107/mo in its outreach plans.

Cold email with unlimited email accounts and unlimited warmup, uploaded contacts, a built-in CRM with Unibox on Hypergrowth, an AI Sales Agent in its Starter bundle, and an AI Reply Agent in its Scale bundle. Its lead plans add a database it describes as 450M+ B2B leads, paid in credits.The page says "Start free" and "No credit card required". It does not state a trial length.Emails a month: Growth 5,000, Hypergrowth 125,000, Light Speed 500,000. Uploaded contacts: 1,000, 25,000, 100,000.Pricing pageChecked
lemlist
  • Email: $55/mo, shown beside a struck-through $69
  • Multichannel: $87/mo, shown beside a struck-through $109
  • Enterprise: custom
  • Lead data enrichment add-on: $16/mo for 2,000 credits, beside a struck-through $20
  • Buying intent signals add-on: $21/mo for 100 signals, beside a struck-through $29

The billing toggle offers Monthly, Quarterly (save 10%) and Yearly (save 20%). The figures above are the ones shown when we checked. The page text does not say which billing term they are.

Email plan: unlimited users and email senders, 50,000 emails a month, an email and phone number finder, a lead database it describes as 650M+ leads, warm-up and deliverability tools, CRM integrations and an API. Multichannel adds 5 senders per user, LinkedIn automation, SMS automation and a call dialer, with WhatsApp as an add-on; its FAQ lists SMS and WhatsApp as add-ons.Its FAQ describes a 14-day free trial with 200 credits, and a banner offers a 30-day free trial. The page does not say whether a card is required.Email: 50,000 emails a month. Multichannel: 5 senders per user, unlimited emails and messages.Pricing pageChecked
Mailmeteor
  • Free: $0
  • Starter: $5.99 per user/mo
  • Premium: $17.99 per user/mo
  • Professional: $35.99 per user/mo

The yearly toggle says "3 months free" and shows no yearly amounts. The page says taxes may apply.

Mail merge from Gmail, Google Sheets or Excel with an email tracker, templates and scheduling. Starter adds email verification, reply detection and Zapier. Mailmeteor's Premium plan adds 5 follow-ups, 1 email warmup, AI auto drafts and bounce detection. Professional adds inbox rotation, pipelines, CRM integration and 10 follow-ups.A free plan, which the page says needs no credit card. The page mentions no trial of the paid plans.Emails a day (a month): Free 50 (500), Starter 250 (5,000), Mailmeteor's Premium plan 1,000 (30,000), Professional 2,000 (60,000). Senders: 1, 1, 5 and 10. Its FAQ says @gmail.com accounts can send up to 500 a day.Pricing pageChecked

What each one lists

  • Mailshake. Starter: mail accounts from any provider, email sequences, A/B testing, AI email writing (SHAKESpeare), unlimited email warmup and verification. Email Outreach adds email rotation, a unified inbox, Salesforce, Pipedrive and HubSpot. Sales Engagement adds a power dialer with 5 phone numbers. Data Finder credits are included and sold as an add-on.
  • Instantly. Cold email with unlimited email accounts and unlimited warmup, uploaded contacts, a built-in CRM with Unibox on Hypergrowth, an AI Sales Agent in its Starter bundle, and an AI Reply Agent in its Scale bundle. Its lead plans add a database it describes as 450M+ B2B leads, paid in credits.
  • lemlist. Email plan: unlimited users and email senders, 50,000 emails a month, an email and phone number finder, a lead database it describes as 650M+ leads, warm-up and deliverability tools, CRM integrations and an API. Multichannel adds 5 senders per user, LinkedIn automation, SMS automation and a call dialer, with WhatsApp as an add-on; its FAQ lists SMS and WhatsApp as add-ons.
  • Mailmeteor. Mail merge from Gmail, Google Sheets or Excel with an email tracker, templates and scheduling. Starter adds email verification, reply detection and Zapier. Mailmeteor's Premium plan adds 5 follow-ups, 1 email warmup, AI auto drafts and bounce detection. Professional adds inbox rotation, pipelines, CRM integration and 10 follow-ups.
  • Rocketship. It finds buyers by job title, industry and place, with work emails. It reads each company's website before the first email, sends from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting on your calendar.

Setup and trial

  • Mailshake. No free trial. The FAQ says "we collect payment up front."
  • Instantly. The page says "Start free" and "No credit card required". It does not state a trial length.
  • lemlist. Its FAQ describes a 14-day free trial with 200 credits, and a banner offers a 30-day free trial. The page does not say whether a card is required.
  • Mailmeteor. A free plan, which the page says needs no credit card. The page mentions no trial of the paid plans.

Before an insurance agent sends

Insurance marketing is regulated state by state, and many carriers set rules for what their appointed agents send. Check your state's rules and your carriers' guidance before you send, and keep a record of what you sent and to whom.

Rocketship, in the same terms

Rocketship is the customer acquisition engine for founders, startups and growing businesses. It finds buyers by job title, industry and place, with work emails. It reads each company's website before the first email, sends from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting on your calendar.

Every plan finds, emails, follows up and books. Finding people on Reddit, Quora and LinkedIn who ask for what you sell starts on Launch. Extra credits are 1,000 for $45.

  • Starter, $12 a month: 250 credits a month (about 62 new people with work emails), up to 20 emails a day from 1 inbox.
  • Launch, $24.99 a month: 500 credits a month (about 125 new people with work emails), up to 70 emails a day from 1 inbox.
  • Frontier, $79 a month: 1,500 credits a month (about 375 new people with work emails), up to 210 emails a day from up to 3 inboxes.
  • Mission Control, $1,499 a month: 30,000 credits a month (about 7,500 new people with work emails), up to 3,500 emails a day from up to 50 inboxes.

Have your AI salesperson send these for you

It writes and sends them from your Gmail, follows up and books the meeting.

7-day free trial on every monthly plan. Card required, cancel any time. See every plan

Questions people ask

Which of these has a free trial?
Mailshake: No free trial. The FAQ says "we collect payment up front." Instantly: The page says "Start free" and "No credit card required". It does not state a trial length. lemlist: Its FAQ describes a 14-day free trial with 200 credits, and a banner offers a 30-day free trial. The page does not say whether a card is required. Mailmeteor: A free plan, which the page says needs no credit card. The page mentions no trial of the paid plans.
Do these connect to an agency management system?
That is not a column in the table, so check each tool's integrations page. Mailshake lists Salesforce, Pipedrive and HubSpot on its Email Outreach plan, and lemlist lists CRM integrations. Rocketship includes a CRM: a pipeline, people and companies, deals and tasks.
Can I find the businesses to email as well?
Rocketship finds buyers by job title, industry and place, with work emails. Instantly sells lead credits as separate plans and Mailshake sells a Data Finder add-on.
What does Rocketship cost?
Starter $12, Launch $24.99, Frontier $79, Mission Control $1,499 a month. 7-day free trial on every monthly plan. Card required, cancel any time.

Each price is quoted from the tool's own pricing page on the date in its row. Prices change, so check the linked page before you buy.