A lead guarantee guarantees a count, and the count is only as good as the contract's definition of "lead". It can be a count of names, of replies or of meetings held, sometimes with a refund or a make-up delivery if the count is missed. Customers are the one thing no agency can deliver on its own, because whether your buyer signs is outside its control. The definition is the contract. Read it before the price. A promise of 30 leads where a lead is any person who opened an email is worth very little. The same 30 where a lead is a person who met the standard you wrote down is worth the money.
This page is for someone about to buy leads or outreach from an agency or a list vendor. It sets out the five kinds of guarantee, the arithmetic of what each is worth, the one federal source on how a guarantee should be described, and the questions to ask. It is not a verdict on any company, and nothing in it is legal advice.
The five kinds of guarantee
| The guarantee | What it promises | What to pin down |
|---|---|---|
| Contacts | A number of names and emails | Are the addresses real, and are they your buyers? |
| Replies or "leads" | A number of people who wrote back | Does "no thanks" count? |
| Qualified leads | People who meet criteria | Who wrote the criteria, and who decides? |
| Meetings | Calls that were booked, or held | Booked or held? A no-show is a different count |
| Money back or a re-run | A refund or more work if the number is missed | Full price or part, and how long you have to ask |
A guarantee of revenue is the one to be most careful with. No outreach company controls whether your buyer signs. A promise of a return on what you spend should come with the formula and the evidence, and you should expect the cap on what they will pay if it is missed.
What the guarantee is worth: a worked example
The numbers here are assumptions to show the method. Suppose an agency charges $3,000 a month and guarantees 20 leads. That sounds like $150 a lead (3,000 divided by 20). Now apply a stricter definition. Suppose 20 leads delivered, and when you apply your standard, 5 are qualified, because 15 were the wrong role or the wrong size of company. Suppose 2 of the 5 become meetings held. You pay $3,000 for 2 meetings, which is $1,500 each. Suppose one of those closes at $4,000: you spent $3,000 to win $4,000. The headline $150 a lead and the real cost per customer, $3,000, are not close. The guarantee was honored and the price was still high, because the guarantee never covered the thing you needed.
Now write the guarantee against the thing you need. If it said "5 qualified meetings held with a decision maker at a company of 20 to 200 people, or the month is refunded", the same $3,000 would be tested at the end of the month on 5 meetings. If 2 came, you would get your money back and not have a dispute about the word "lead".
What the FTC says about guarantees
The FTC's Guides for the Advertising of Warranties and Guarantees, 16 CFR Part 239, section 239.3, read on 2026-11-15, say a seller should use the terms "Satisfaction Guarantee," "Money Back Guarantee" or similar representations in advertising only if it refunds the full purchase price of the advertised product at the purchaser's request (239.3(a)). Paragraph (b) says an advertisement that mentions a satisfaction guarantee or similar representation should disclose, with such clarity and prominence as will be noticed and understood by prospective purchasers, any material limitations or conditions that apply. These are guides, and the text says "should", not "must", but they show what a plain description looks like. A guarantee with its limits in small print, or a "money back" that returns part of the price, does not match the way the guides say to describe it. The guides cover an advertised product's guarantee; they do not tell you how a lead should be counted. That is for you to write.
Writing the guarantee into the agreement
A guarantee that is not in the contract is a sales line. Ask for four things in writing: the definition of the thing being guaranteed (for example, a meeting held with a named kind of person at a company of a stated size), the period it is measured over, what you receive if it is missed (a refund of the full month, not a credit towards the next one, if that is what you were promised), and how long you have to claim. Add who counts the result and what evidence they show. A short clause you both can read in a minute prevents the month-end argument. The agreement is a document you should have a lawyer in your state read, because contract rules differ by state.
Questions to ask before you sign
- How do you define a lead? Show me the sentence.
- Who decides if a lead meets the definition, you or me, and what happens in a disagreement?
- Where do the people come from, and can I see 20 of them before the month starts?
- If the number is missed, do I get a refund, credits or more work, and for how much?
- How long after delivery can I claim, and do I have to ask in writing?
- Do leads that bounce, opt out or are duplicates count toward the number?
- Am I paying the same amount if the number is missed by a little as by a lot?
For the wider choice between buying leads, paying by the lead and paying a retainer, see are buying leads worth it, pay per lead vs retainer and lead generation companies.
What Rocketship does about this
Rocketship does not guarantee meetings or results. It meters work instead: a person found with an email is 4 credits, charged only when an email is found, so the cost of a name is a known number before anything is sent. It finds business buyers, emails them from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting. Plans start at $12 a month, with a 7-day trial and a card required, on the pricing page.