To choose a lead generation company, ask the same 12 questions of every candidate and compare the written answers: who they will contact, where the data comes from, whose mailboxes send, if you see messages first, what counts as a meeting, how they are paid, and what you own when you leave. A company that answers in specifics and agrees to put them in the contract is worth a second call. One that answers in adjectives is not.

The price of the service matters less than the unit it is priced in. A $3,000 retainer and a $200-per-meeting fee are not comparable until you know how many meetings you expect and what a meeting is. A worked comparison is below, after the questions.

The 12 questions

About the people they will contact

  1. Who exactly will you contact for me? Ask for the job titles, company sizes and locations in writing, and a sample of 10 real names from the list before you sign. If you cannot say whether those 10 are your buyers, you have found a problem early.
  2. Where does the data come from? You want a plain answer, not "proprietary sources." Ask what happens when an address bounces and if you get the list at the end.
  3. Who else do you work for in my market? A company running campaigns for your direct competitor at the same time is a risk. Ask for a clause on it.

About how they send

  1. Whose mailboxes and domains do the emails go from? Yours, theirs, or new ones set up for the campaign? New domains protect your main one, and they also belong to someone, and that someone should be you.
  2. Do I see every message before it goes out? The emails carry your name or your product's. You are entitled to read them first, and to stop a campaign the same day you see a problem.
  3. Who handles an opt-out or a complaint, and how fast? The FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide (16 CFR Part 316, read on 2026-11-15) says you must honor an opt-out within 10 business days, every message needs a valid physical postal address, and "you can't contract away your legal responsibility to comply with the law." The company that sends the email and the company whose product is promoted can both be held responsible, so the contract should name who runs the suppression list.

About results and money

  1. What counts as a meeting? Booked on a calendar, held, or held with a person who fits the criteria you agreed? A low per-meeting price can hide a loose definition, so get it in writing.
  2. Who answers the replies, and how fast? A reply that sits unread is a meeting nobody tried to book. Ask who reads them and who decides what counts as a yes.
  3. How are you paid, and what is the minimum term? Retainer, per meeting, per lead, or a mix. Ask what you owe if you stop in month two. The trade-offs between retainers and per-result fees are in pay per lead vs retainer.
  4. What do you report, and how often? Ask for the real numbers: people contacted, replies, meetings held and, from you, deals. Not opens, which say little about whether anyone wants to buy.

About leaving

  1. What do I own at the end? The list, the reply history, the domains and the copy. Get the export format in writing.
  2. What happens if it is not working by the second month? Ask for that plan in writing. A company that says it never happens has not planned for it.

A worked comparison

Suppose two companies, called Agency A and Agency B here, quote you for the same work. Both say they will contact owners of 20 to 100 person logistics firms in the Midwest.

  • Agency A quotes $3,000 a month with a three-month minimum.
  • Agency B quotes $200 for each held meeting with a person who fits the criteria, with no minimum.

Assume 10 held meetings in a month. Agency A costs $3,000, or $300 a meeting. Agency B costs 10 times $200, or $2,000. The break-even is 15 meetings (15 times $200 is $3,000). Below 15 held meetings a month, per-meeting is cheaper. Above 15, the retainer is.

Now suppose, as another assumption, that 1 in 5 held meetings becomes a customer worth $4,000 in the first year. Ten meetings gives 2 customers and $8,000. Agency A's cost per customer is $3,000 divided by 2, which is $1,500. Agency B's is $2,000 divided by 2, which is $1,000. Both are below the $4,000 a customer is worth, and a lot depends on your own close rate. If the rate is 1 in 10, the same 10 meetings give 1 customer, so Agency A costs $3,000 per customer and Agency B $2,000, against $4,000 of first-year revenue. Agency A's margin is then thin. Run your own number before you choose the structure.

What these companies sell to smaller buyers, and what they charge, is covered in lead generation companies for smaller buyers, the cost of an agency against software is in cold email agency vs software, and a quick range for the whole category is in how much lead generation costs.

Red flags in the sales call

  • A guaranteed number of meetings. Nobody controls whether buyers reply, so ask what definition of a meeting the guarantee rests on.
  • No sample of the list or the email before you sign.
  • "Proprietary" data that cannot be described.
  • Reports that lead with opens and clicks.
  • A refusal to put the answers above in the contract.

Two calls that tell you the most

Ask for two references who have been clients for at least six months, and put the same three things to each: what did they get in month one, what went wrong, and would they sign again. Then ask the company to explain a campaign that did not work. The way they describe a failure shows you how they will treat yours.

If you are weighing a company against doing it yourself, the alternative to hiring a lead generation agency page lays out the option. Rocketship runs the finding, emailing, replies and booking from your own Gmail from $12 a month, with a 7-day trial and a card required, and plans are on the pricing page. It does not guarantee meetings and will not close the deal.