A pay per lead company charges you a fixed fee each time it hands you a contact who asked about what you sell, whether or not that person ever buys. The fee depends on whether the lead is shared with other buyers or exclusive to you, and on who verifies it. The lead itself is usually a license to contact, not something you own outright, so read the contract for who holds the consent record, what counts as a refund, and whether the same person was sold to others.
In this example, Marcus runs a commercial cleaning company with 14 crews. He is offered leads from a pay per lead company at $45 each. He wants to know whether $45 is cheap. The number that answers that is what a customer costs, and it depends on what he actually gets for $45.
The four kinds of pay per lead
Shared leads. One person fills in a form, and the company sells that inquiry to several buyers. The price per lead is lowest. Speed matters most here, and by the time you call, someone else may have the contract.
Exclusive leads. The inquiry is sold to you alone. The price per lead is higher, and what you get for it is no competing calls and a better chance that the person is still listening.
Pay per qualified lead. An agency or call center screens contacts against criteria you agree on (company size, role, a stated need) and charges for each one that passes. How it differs from a monthly fee is in pay per lead vs retainer.
Pay per booked appointment. You pay when a meeting is on your calendar, and sometimes only when the person shows up. It costs the most per unit and puts the most of the risk on the seller. Whether the meeting turns into a customer is still yours to win.
What a customer costs, with numbers
The conversion rates below are assumptions to show the method, not industry figures. Replace them with yours after your first 50 leads.
Marcus buys 100 shared leads at $45 each, which is $4,500. Suppose he reaches 40 of them, quotes 10 and wins 3. That is $4,500 for 3 customers, or $1,500 per customer. Now he buys 100 exclusive leads at $120 each, which is $12,000. Suppose he reaches 70, quotes 25 and wins 9. That is $12,000 for 9 customers, or about $1,333 per customer. The exclusive leads cost 2.7 times as much per lead and slightly less per customer, because more of them answered the phone.
Now compare to what a customer is worth. If a cleaning contract brings in $1,800 of gross profit in its first year, the shared leads leave $300 per customer ($1,800 minus $1,500) and the exclusive leads leave about $467 ($1,800 minus $1,333). Change one assumption (say he wins 2 of the shared 100 instead of 3, which is $2,250 per customer) and the shared leads lose $450 per customer. Two things move the result more than the sticker price: how many leads are reachable, and how fast you call.
Who owns the lead
A lead is a name, a contact detail and a record of what the person agreed to. You mostly pay for the third thing, and the contract decides who holds it. Ask these before you sign:
- Is this lead sold to anyone else, and if so, how many? Ask for it in writing, not on a sales call.
- May you keep the contact and email them again later, or must you delete after a set period?
- Does the vendor keep the consent record (the form wording, the time, the number or address entered) and give it to you if the person complains?
- What counts as an invalid lead, how long do you have to report one, and is the refund cash or credit?
- Where did the lead come from: the vendor's own site, a purchased list or a partner?
- Can the vendor resell the lead to your competitor next week?
Treat any answer that is not in the contract as a no. If a vendor cannot tell you how a lead is made, treat the lead as a list of unknown origin.
The legal piece buyers forget
If you call or text a lead, the consent has to cover you. For telemarketing calls or texts that use an automatic dialer or a prerecorded or artificial voice, FCC rules require the called party's prior express written consent (47 CFR 64.1200(a)(2), with the definition in 64.1200(f)(9), read 2026-11-15). In 2023 the FCC adopted a rule that would have limited each consent to one named seller, a so-called one-to-one rule. On January 24, 2025 the Eleventh Circuit vacated that part of the 2023 order (Part III.D) in Insurance Marketing Coalition v. FCC (No. 24-10277; opinion read on the court's site, 2026-11-15), holding that its new consent restrictions conflict with the ordinary statutory meaning of "prior express consent" in 47 U.S.C. 227(b) and so exceeded the FCC's authority. The court did not set aside the older rule that telemarketing robocalls need prior express written consent. That removes one federal restriction on resold consent. It does not remove your duty to check that a person agreed to hear from someone like you, and several states have their own telemarketing laws. For the rules on cold calls and texts, see is AI cold calling legal.
Email is separate. Under the CAN-SPAM Act (15 U.S.C. 7704(a)(5)(A), read 2026-11-15) any commercial email you send needs clear identification as an advertisement or solicitation, a working opt-out and your valid physical postal address, whoever sold you the address. The law puts those duties on the sender, which is you. Is cold email legal covers the rest.
What the arithmetic rewards
The numbers above reward a product that sells quickly after a short inquiry, a margin high enough to absorb leads that never buy, and a team that calls within minutes. They punish a sale that takes months, a buyer you need to know before you spend time, and a wish to build a list you keep. Are bought leads worth it goes through the cases, and lead generation companies for small businesses lists the types of vendor.
How it compares to paying for the work
Pay per lead charges for an outcome you do not control. The other models charge for the work. A monthly retainer charges for an agency's effort. Software charges for tools or credits and leaves the outcome to you. Lead generation agency alternatives sets the options side by side.
Rocketship does not sell leads and does not charge per result. It finds the business buyers you describe, emails them from your own Gmail, follows up, answers replies and books the meeting. You pay in credits for the work: 4 credits for each new person found with an email, nothing if no email is found, and nothing for searching and counting. Plans start at $12 a month, with a 7-day trial, card required. It cannot promise that any of them buys.